The best blog on publishing? Publishing blogs (III)

Over the last couple of weeks or so, Monographer’s blog has run a mini-series on blogs on publishing. The blogs chosen for, as it were, the bronze and silver medals were not amongst the best known. In contrast, the blog chosen here for the gold medal is highly popular. Perhaps nominating The Scholarly Kitchen: What’s hot and cooking in scholarly publishing even runs the risk of launching a ‘dog bites person’ story.

The Scholarly Kitchen was established by The Society for Scholarly Publishing in 2008. It is edited by Kent Anderson and Phil Davis and currently has eight other contributors. Its aims – expressed on the blog in very worthy, even grave, terms – may be paraphrased as ‘writing about interesting stuff to do with scholarly publishing and its contexts’. Regular themes include digitization, developments in libraries, university presses, and higher education, and issues of IP and publishing ethics. Generally, the blog is forward-looking.

The use of a broad team of contributors enables the blog to maintain a high standard while publishing frequently. The standard isn’t invariably high. Sometimes posts miss their mark a little. For example, Reconsidering the Abstract doesn’t seem to me fully cooked. It is as if the post wants to announce the death of the abstract, but can’t quite bring itself to do so.

I’m not entirely convinced by blog’s recently launched ‘Stick to your Ribs‘ feature, in which every week the editor selects a post the blog’s archive (“A post that the Chefs and [the editor] agree has long-term appeal, bears repeated readings, and has shaped thinking over time”). Is the blog running out of steam a little, I wonder?

In general, though, the blog is fresh, vigilant, and thought-provoking. It is unafraid to take an independent line. As an example of a typically impressive post, I’d nominate Publishing through the Wormhole,which (similarly to Monographer’s Blog in ‘From Monograph to Mesograph?‘ below) takes its theme from the perception that “books and articles are the length they are because of the economics of their distribution”.


5 Responses to “The best blog on publishing? Publishing blogs (III)”

  1. Thanks for recognizing the Scholarly Kitchen in this manner. We’re actually hard at work on a redesign, which will debut soon. The “Stick to Your Ribs” feature you mention wasn’t created because we’re running out of steam, but because our current design makes it hard to keep some great posts front-and-center. We strive to publish daily, so a reverse-chronology listing pushes down too soon stuff that deserves a longer shelf-life.

    One of the great aspects of the blog currently is our commentators — the comments we get are very useful, and outnumber posts by about 7:1 on average, with some posts generating dozens of useful comments.

    Thanks again for the shout-out!

Please add your response

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: